The Splenda comparison

Standard vs. Splenda: the published numbers

See calories, carbs and sugar side by side, with an explanation of the source’s Detox carb discrepancy.

Published May 14, 2026Reviewed November 7, 2026Sources & limitations

The guide publishes alternate calories, carbohydrate and sugar for 26 adult and kids smoothies. Blimey Limey has the largest listed calorie difference: 510 → 220 per serving.

Compare the published recipes

Adult smoothies are 24 fl oz; kids smoothies are 12 fl oz. The source says most smoothies use turbinado unless otherwise requested. Replacing it with Splenda does not remove sugar from fruit or other ingredients.

Scroll inside this table to see every column →

Standard and Splenda recipe comparison
Smoothie & servingStandard calSplenda calCalories fewerStandard sugarSplenda sugar
Blimey Limey
24 fl oz
510220290120g47g
Acai Berry Boost
24 fl oz
470240230102g44g
Avocolada
24 fl oz
580350230107g49g
Bahama Mama
24 fl oz
520290230112g54g
Beach Bum (Chocolate Frappe)
24 fl oz
540310230108g49g
Beach Bum (White Chocolate Frappe)
24 fl oz
560330230109g51g
Blueberry Bliss
24 fl oz
34011023074g16g
Island Green
24 fl oz
43020023097g33g
Jetty Punch
24 fl oz
36013023076g18g
Kiwi Quencher
24 fl oz
490260230109g51g
Mango Magic
24 fl oz
450220230104g46g
Mango Monsoon
24 fl oz
540310230127g69g
Mocha Madness
24 fl oz
810580230163g105g
Paradise Point
24 fl oz
42019023091g33g
Peanut Butter Cup
24 fl oz
680450230106g48g
Peanut Paradise with Pea
24 fl oz
73050023090g31g
Peanut Paradise with Whey
24 fl oz
70047023091g33g
Pomegranate Plunge
24 fl oz
540310230125g67g
Sunshine Smoothie
24 fl oz
510280230113g55g
Sunrise Sunset
24 fl oz
460230230106g48g
Tropical Dragon Passion
24 fl oz
41018023091g32g
Kids Jetty Junior
12 fl oz
1806012037g9g
Chia Banana Boost
24 fl oz
68057011073g45g
Kids Awesome Chocolate
12 fl oz
25014011051g23g
Kids Lil' Limeberry
12 fl oz
170809039g18g
Detox Island Green
24 fl oz
210210039g39g

The Detox exception and source discrepancy

Detox Island Green is not sweetened with turbinado by default. The guide lists 210 calories and 39g sugar for both recipes, but carbohydrate changes from 53g to 60g. We show both values as published and flag the discrepancy, rather than invent a correction.

Use the recipe you actually order

Select “With Splenda” on each eligible smoothie in the calculator. You can keep one smoothie standard and another with Splenda. There is no assumption that every drink in an order has the same recipe.

Source and scope

Tables are computed from the same core dataset as the calculator: Official nutrition PDF , pages 1–2. Published May 14, 2026; checked November 7, 2026. Historical entries are excluded. The source is a snapshot, not a live availability feed.